|
A
Better Box Costs Too Much...Or Does It?
By
Len Oppenheimer
A typical
scenario:
Shelia
wanted to purchase the cheapest box for her products. "It only gets
thrown away at the end of the day and that costs too much,"
said Shelia. She wanted to put her money into a quality product
not a quality shipping box.
Don't you
believe that a quality box and package is part of the overall quality
of your product?
Shelia
was focused solely on the price of the box, not the cost of the
box as it relates to other aspects of her business. Shelia insisted
that her business model didn't work with the better box and so Shelia
felt she had what was needed ... or did she?
What Shelia
wanted was to become more profitable and have better results by
keeping down her costs. You can understand her concerns and keep
them in mind when we look at the bigger picture.
After the
first few weeks of shipping the damages started rolling in.
"Not many",
claimed Shelia.
The actual
number was 1.5% per a month on average.
Let's look
at the cost of the damages as it related to Shelia's company:
The
Parcel Delivery Company
We spoke to the account representative at Speedy-Fast, the shipping
company that made deliveries for Shelia. He confirmed that rarely
was Shelia's company ever reimbursed for their claims. (The shipping
companies always feel it could be packaged better). The whole package
was essentially a loss.
The
Sales Team
Shelia's sales staff had plenty to say about the damages. They had
to field a call from a stressed out, unhappy customer. The customers
were relying on a perfect shipment and it did not happen.
The company
policy is to get a new item out right away, but right away meant
filling out new paperwork, writing up a damage claim, and getting
an expedited delivery to replace what was lost. It frequently meant
taking the time to call back and relay tracking numbers, and in
some cases offer a discount as a way to make up for the loss.
The
Shipping and Receiving Manager
The shipping manager had to deal with arranging a pick up for the
damaged items. He was always rushing to get out the new replacement
product, and frequently had to set up an expedited service to the
customer with the Speedy-Fast to make up for the lost time.
A receiving
manager was getting the damaged product back into the warehouse
and had to deal with paperwork associated with the whole process.
YOUR
BOX GUY TIP: Customer satisfaction is delivering
on what you say you will do, not making up for what didn't happen
in the first place. Your box is typically less than 5% of your products
makeup and a smaller part of the sales percentage. It is, however,
the largest part of the first impression and contact your customers
will have with the product you have sold them.
The costs
of the damages added up real fast:
Cost of
Shelia's goods before handling and packing were $25.
The labor
to pack and fill paperwork for shipping was $2.00.
Actual
shipping varied but averaged $6.00 per parcel for our purposes.(Really
it was more as the greatest damage came to items that spent the
longest in transit due to distance shipped and therefore cost the
most.)
When a
"damage call" came in the sales staff did everything except find
new customers, sell more products or improve customer satisfaction.
A sale is where the real profits for Shelia's company were. Unfortunately
the sales team was busy doing everything but selling in this circumstance.
In fact
their 15 minutes of handling each damage complaint could have been
used to call on prospects, or answer the phone of a customer who
wanted to place an order but instead was put on hold or into a voicemail.
Let's put the cost at a very low $5.00.
The customers'
were unsatisfied and stressed at dealing with the problem. (You
name the cost!)
Fulfillment
had to repack another order for $2.00 in labor again. Expedited
shipping service to make up for the lost time was $12.00 because
customer satisfaction was the company goal.
Getting
the damaged item back (if you even choose to do so) $6.00 again.
The possibility of disappointing other customers because shipping
did not have time to get everything out for the day..........you
see where this is going.
Packages
shipped per month were 1000. 1.5% damages equals 15 packages. All
told the replacement costs totaled $52.00 per package. Shelia really
spent $780.00 per month trying to save money!
The additional
investment of an upgraded box was 12%. It amounted to $70.00 per
thousand boxes. This against $780 in replacement costs. Imagine
if Shelia starts to sell twice as many packages a month?
We went
over the findings and Shelia immediately upgraded to the heavier
boxes. She even decided to upgrade the boxes to white from brown.
They were "handled" better, looked more valuable, and the printing
really stood out. (See Len Oppenheimer's article on using graphics to increase your sales
and profits)
Len Oppenheimer's article on using graphics to increase your sales
and profits)
Packaging
problem solved. Profits are up. If you don't invest the funds to
do it right, where will you get the funds to do it over?
REPRINT PERMISSION ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Reprint permission granted in part or whole when the following
credit appears: "Reprinted with permission from "Len Oppenheimer's
Packaging Success Newsletter. (Copyright, 2003, Len Oppenheimer,
YourBoxGuy.com)
What
can Your Box Guy do for you?
|